The Great Confusion: Why Does Every Workout System Seem To Work?

Steve Shaw
Written By: Steve Shaw
August 22nd, 2013
Updated: June 13th, 2020
28.5K Reads
Here's the great muscle building mystery: why is it that so many workout systems appear to work, yet 90% of lifters are struggling to make decent gains? Find out...

Here are 2 conflicting statements that most of us know to be true:

1) Every Workout System Works. While wars rage over which workout system is better, the bottom line is that everything seems to work. People are getting results on Wendler’s 531, Stronglifts, Starting Strength, low volume training, high volume training and even rest pause training.

2) Few People See Solid Results. You see it on every Internet lifting forum - 10% of lifters are making great progress, while 90% of lifters make extremely slow progress. Hitting a 250 pound bench press, or building a 16 inch arm seems like an impossible task.

Now for the obvious question: if everything seems to work, why are so few people making decent progress? The answer to this mystery is quite simple, when you analyze the real keys to success.

Does Every Workout Program Work?

Nearly every program works, yes. Even inefficient, disorganized programs stuffed with too much (or too little) volume and/or sub-par exercise choices can still result in decent muscle gains because of this truth...

If you stay consistent and don’t miss workouts, eat enough calories and protein to grow, and get a lot stronger than you are now, you will build muscle and strength.

End of story. That’s the magic secret. That’s why most every program seems to work.

How many times have you seen some guy with huge arms post up his workout plan, and it looks like a chaotic mess? My guess is more than a few times. Most likely this individual will also think he’s stumbled upon some amazing secret, such as drop sets build muscle better than anything, when in reality the real key was found in his strength increases, consistency and food intake.

So Do Workout Programs Matter?

Massive Muscular ManEven though you can make good progress using nearly any workout system, it doesn’t mean this approach is optimal. Most lifters ignore mastering form fundamentals, force too much training volume, overwork arms, abs and chest, avoid the most challenging but impactful lifts (squats, deadlifts, etc.), and substitute in advanced training techniques such as rest-pause, drop sets, supersets, instead of focusing more of their energy on progression of weight (getting stronger).

Programs do matter. It’s best to stick with a system that has a good reputation, and has been tried and tested. Which workout system is best for you? Hard to say.

Most quality programs are comprised of the same basic (and effective) exercises, work within the 5-12 rep range (great for muscle and strength building), and have you training about 3-4 days per week max. Pick a system that most motivates you to hit the gym. If you don’t like the "popular system of the week", that’s ok.

Pick something you do like, and STICK WITH IT. Jumping from program to program to program is one of the worst mistakes you can make. Remember, programs aren’t magic, progression of weight is. Keep your focus on getting stronger.

Progression - Are Strength Increases Really The Key?

Yes. There is no other way. There are no weak bodybuilders, just as there are no frail and unmuscular top-level powerlifters. Strength is required to build muscle, and muscle helps with strength building.

Whether you are looking to build muscle or only interest in getting stronger, the initial path is the same. You must spend a period of time getting stronger in standard rep ranges (5-12 reps in most cases). During this period of aggressive progression, you will also build plenty of muscle.

But, but, but..."bodybuilder X" say he doesn’t train for strength gains. True! He may not train specifically for strength gains. He may focus on the pump, or the mind-muscle connection, but guess what...he still requires progression of weight to build muscle.

The pump without progression of weight is useless. The mind-muscle connection without progression of weight is useless. While there is certainly nothing wrong with using these tools, they still require you to get a lot stronger than you are now.

I want you to understand an important points with regards to bodybuilders who state they don’t specifically train for strength gains. That point is this: despite stating they don’t train for strength, to a man they are still nearly as strong as elite level powerlifters. Nearly. Or at least within shouting distance.

I know this to be true because I work in the industry. I have spoken with, documented and trained with many of the best natural bodybuilders in the world. These bodybuilders AREN’T weak. Each of them has worked hard to pack on muscle mass, and are amazingly strong in their own right.

Doug Miller has a Youtube video in which he deadlifts 405 pounds for 20 reps. The “giant killer” Shaun Clarida has a Youtube video in which he deep squats over 500 pounds for reps. I’ve also seen first hand Mr. North Carolina Joe Ohrablo do dumbbell bench presses with 150 pound dumbbells, and wheelchair bodybuilder Rich Knapp do one arm pullups with his wife on his back.

Does any of this sound weak to you? Absolutely not. It’s the norm, not the exception.

To get big, you must get stronger. You don’t have to become a powerlifter, training with heavy singles and triples, but you do have to get a lot stronger than you are now. To get strong, you must get bigger. You don’t have to become a bodybuilder, building up every minor muscle group to its maximal size, but you do need to get a lot bigger than you are now.


Consistency - Just How Dedicated Are You?

So now that you know just how important strength increases are, let’s talk about another issue holding trainees back...lack of consistency. How many workouts are you missing each month? Do you deload or reset weight every time you have a sub-par training day?

If you’re missing more than a handful of workouts per year, or frequently resetting weight (even though you haven’t built much strength), you are not dedicated enough to expect gains. I’m sure it hurts to hear this, but it’s the truth. Those that want it don’t make excuses. They get to the gym and put in the necessary work.

More than this, they LIKE going to the gym. They look forward to training, and eat, sleep and dream about progress. You can’t fake dedication. Successful lifters don’t half-ass anything. They plan their meals and give everything they can on any given day - even bad days.

Successful lifters realize that results require a long term commitment. They understand that bad days will happen, and don’t become alarmed when their performance is sub-par. They certainly are not quick to deload, or reset weight.

Dedication might require you to make a few lifestyle changes. Think about the areas of your life that are unbalanced. Are you drinking too much, or staying up late every night playing the Xbox? Are you living on junk food and soda even though you know these habits are unhealthy?

To be successful, and find consistency, you’re going to have to bring some form of balance and self-control into your daily life. If you continue to place yourself in situations that result in sleep deprivation or hangovers, you’re going to miss workouts.

Another area that trips up many trainees is lifting frequency. They try to be superheroes, training 5 to 7 days per week thing more is better. This is nonsense. Better is better. Besides, what good is using a 6 day split if you’re missing 2 workouts a week because of other life commitments, fatigue, etc?

Let’s be reasonable here. Set aside the notion that you need to live in the gym to achieve results. Did you know that most powerlifters train a max of 4 days per week? True. They might do some conditioning work on off days if they have time, but they are not living in the gym lifting weights 6 days a week.

I know a few advanced bodybuilders that lift 5 days a week, but guess what? You’re not an advanced bodybuilder. In fact, you’ve barely built any muscle mass at all. Instead of trying to kill yourself, back track, slow down, and build a solid base.

Posted on: Mon, 02/10/2014 - 03:07

I'm around 24% bf and I'm on a strength routine which is basically in the 5-10 rep range .It's full body training with mostly compound exercises. Main exercises are Squats,Deads,Bench Presses,Pull ups, Rows, military presses and power cleans. When i"m not sore i do a lot of rear delts and laterals. Hit the arms with mostly compound movements. However, the trainer at the gym has started ridiculing me for my workout and not following his 20+ rep fat loss work out. I'm 106kg and 192cm tall and i can squat 125 for 5, dead-lift 170 for 5 and bench 110 for 6+ reps. Do you think my routine is fine for fat loss and overall strength improvement.? Sorry it was a bit long winded.

Posted on: Tue, 10/18/2016 - 05:53

Yes, what you do is great! Don't listen to the trainer. His plan sounds stupid. Amazing who gets to call themselves trainers these days.

You sound really strong, just cut the fat with following a good diet plan and you will be golden!

Posted on: Fri, 08/30/2013 - 14:57

Amazing Article! You really laid the reality of the journey. It lit a fire under me. Thank you so much!

Posted on: Wed, 08/28/2013 - 09:13

REally great articles i read it very carefully and have found some of my mistake thanks for this article now i'm more fired up to go for it!!!

M&S Team Badge
Posted on: Wed, 08/28/2013 - 11:09

Thanks Kerwin, and smash all your goals.

Posted on: Tue, 08/27/2013 - 21:43

Great article. I've been training relatively serious for the past 1-1.5 years. It has taken this long to begin to figure out what works, what doesn't, and certainly what I need to improve on. Like Steve indicates here, consistency is the key. Diet is just as, if not more, important than the work in the gym. But that too requires consistency. Again, great article Steve. I look forward to reading more.

M&S Team Badge
Posted on: Wed, 08/28/2013 - 01:57

Thanks Drew,and stay strong!

Posted on: Tue, 08/27/2013 - 21:01

Thanks a lot this is really helpful. I struggle with what workout system to use and the fact that being consistent and focusing on gaining strength is more important is very helpful. I'm not gonna lie sometimes I get pretty down cause I'm not seeing the results I want and I think this will help!

M&S Team Badge
Posted on: Wed, 08/28/2013 - 02:01

Hang tough David. Time and progression will serve you well.

Posted on: Tue, 08/27/2013 - 20:30

Of course good form is important, but that doesn't mean you can't lift heavy. It means that you shouldn't lift heavy if you don't have good form.

M&S Team Badge
Posted on: Wed, 08/28/2013 - 02:02

I lift very heavy.

Posted on: Fri, 08/23/2013 - 14:16

Could not agree more. The magic trick to training, is exactly this. Experiment a bit and find what works for you by finding a work out that you enjoy. If you enjoy it, it will work. I can't stand traditional two day split or one body part per day. Sucks for me. I like full body three times a week, compound movements only. I pick the hardest exercises, no db curls here. Deadlifts, squats, weighted pullups and dips, cleans, presses, 5x5... Every week those weights go up, sometimes only a pound or two, but they go up. And guess what? I'm getting results. Oh yeah, and eat.

M&S Team Badge
Posted on: Wed, 08/28/2013 - 02:02

Thanks Brian, and solid advice.

Posted on: Fri, 08/23/2013 - 05:36

Great article Steve I always enjoy reading them!

M&S Team Badge
Posted on: Wed, 08/28/2013 - 02:02

Thanks! Stay strong.

Posted on: Fri, 08/23/2013 - 04:52

But its always important to use good form when lifting right?
Its always easier to lift heavier with bad form, but that wont build muscle right?

M&S Team Badge
Posted on: Fri, 08/23/2013 - 10:42

Absolutely. You always want to be using good form, and working on improving form. I would never recommend sloppy reps that could lead to injury.

Posted on: Fri, 08/23/2013 - 02:13

Very nice article. Thanks!

M&S Team Badge
Posted on: Wed, 08/28/2013 - 02:03

Thank you Zo.